It is true that MF was not as great a writer as say, William Shakespeare , but it doesn't follow that she was "a bad writer". The ED books were mostly geared toward girls, ages six through twelve, and therefore may not be as fun to read for older people , which also happens to be one of the hardest age groups to find good books for. Look through your library shelves for young girls' books, and most of the books you will find there are full of stories of girls living very impure lives.
I know, I've looked. These are the books that encourage girls to live for themselves only, and teach them that they are smarter, and really know more then their parents do. The ED books were a life saver for my sister and I during that time, and not because they were the lesser of all other evils. We both just loved to read, and these were the perfect books for us. I am just asking you to stop, think, and read before you cross them off your list. It's your choice to not read them, but it will also be your loss!
This series is truly one in a million! What do you think? All right, that finishes my rant for now. Since I've told you what I think about ED, now it's your turn to tell me what you think! Thank you for reading the whole post before you comment, and for leaving your name. View all 7 comments. I read this book a long time ago, but seeing as a lot of friends and friends of friends are reading it, I thought I would share my thoughts about it since everything is still pretty fresh in my mind about it. When I was about twelve, I received this book at a birthday party for a friend. Being the Book Dragon I am, I was excited.
So, of course, I started reading it. And I at first, I thought it was racist, but then I realized that this was written about a different time period and when you look I read this book a long time ago, but seeing as a lot of friends and friends of friends are reading it, I thought I would share my thoughts about it since everything is still pretty fresh in my mind about it. And I at first, I thought it was racist, but then I realized that this was written about a different time period and when you look back, this probably wasn't as racist as it could have been.
Don't get me wrong, the flogging of the black servants had me boiling, even at twelve years of age. And I was angry that there were any black servants at all before realizing that this was written about that time.
It didn't make it any better, but I'm sure the author was trying to aim for authenticity. So, moving on from that point, we get to Elsie, who is somehow super mature in her faith for an eight-year-old. I have been a Christian my whole life, but I can tell you at eight years old, I wasn't so spiritually grounded.
She seemed to be able to follow everything in the Bible without hardship, besides her family trying to get her to read books to her young cousin. He raises Elsie to fear him, preventing her from doing the things she usually does, punishing her for things that really aren't her fault, and being as cold-hearted as the family Elsie has been living with. Then one of her dad's friends becomes infatuated with her, claiming he'll take her as his own daughter, but I'm thinking he had other things in mind, which is disgusting.
Because most grown men don't become mesmerized by little girls who aren't their own daughters. Just sayin'.
But, somehow this treatment has Elsie in the best health she's been in and her relationship with her father is great even though he has violent mood swings no one could keep up with. But as I got older, my eyes were opened. And I could see the toxic teachings of this book.
Elsie at Home (The Original Elsie Dinsmore Collection) (Original Elsie Classics)
Now, keep in mind, this was written in and about a different time period. And things were different. But I don't think we should be pushing this book on young girls, telling them this is what they need to read and that this is true faith. True faith is in the Book of Matthew or the Book of John.
Go read the Bible for that. Books written by mere humans, even with good intention, will not be as holy or as God-inspired, as the Word of God Himself. So yeah, that's my two cents, you can take it or leave it. And if you've read this book and you've liked it, well, to each their own. That's all for now. View all 14 comments.
e-book Elsie at Home (The Original Elsie Dinsmore Collection)
Feb 24, Caroline rated it did not like it. I tried to like this book. I really did. But it is perhaps one of the worst books about biblical girlhood I have ever read.
- Beyond All.
- Swing To Bop;
- Married I Can Always Get.
- LINEFFABILE SCIA DELLESISTERE (Italian Edition)!
- Koorong | Unsupported Browser.
- Elsie At Home;
Her faultless adherence to every tiny rule made me believe she was more automaton than human. Despite completing that boring purpose within the first few pages, the storyline has no intention of going anywhere else. By the end of the book, I was wishing Elsie would just go drown herself to stop her incessant weeping and to liven up the stagnating plot. Aside from the technical aspects of the book, I think Martha Finley misses the beauty of Christianity. Therefore, the Christian life is a constant molding and growing process.
- The Lost Esoterical Teachings of Jesus.
- Israel: Federal Research Study and Country Profile with Comprehensive Information, History, and Analysis - Politics, Economy, Military.
- Une rentrée littéraire (Littérature Française) (French Edition).
- The Commodification of Childhood: The Children’s Clothing Industry and the Rise of the Child Consumer.
Although we strive to glorify Christ with our lives, we will never reach perfection here on earth. However, Elsie seems to exist outside this reality in a rigid Utopia of her own. She is awesome and flawless.
- A Note About Editions:.
- Nursing jobs In Canada With 7 Easy Steps!
- elsie dinsmore products for sale | eBay.
- Schizophrenia, An Issue of Psychiatric Clinics - E-Book (The Clinics: Internal Medicine);
- The Sign of the Grail (Major Works).
- Product Description.
- Elsie Dinsmore.
Clinging to such an unrealistic idea can lead to legalism, depression, and even failed marriages. I've heard people try to defend this book by saying, "That's just the way they wrote in the 's. And that's the way girls and society were then. I can think of multiple books written in that same decade e. Stepping Heavenward by Elizabeth Prentiss that are much deeper, much better written, much more encouraging, and much more realistic.
To be completely fair, I have not read the whole Elsie Dinsmore series. But I highly doubt the mindset, message, or writing style behind this first book radically changes later on.
Elsie At Home (Elsie Dinsmore, book 22) by Martha Finley
View all 3 comments. Feb 01, Anna Hutzky rated it it was amazing. I learned that even though nobody may not love you, you can still trust Jesus' love. Dec 21, Briana rated it did not like it Shelves: books-that-disappointed-me. Personally, I find perfect people boring and somewhat annoying. Elsie grated on me a lot She cries incessantly, she's not particularly witty, and she seems to be out of touch with reality. I guess I can understand it for now, because she's young, but in the following books I feel bad for not liking this book, because it really does tell a good message.
Even when you're all alo Personally, I find perfect people boring and somewhat annoying. Even when you're all alone, Jesus is all you need. It would've been better to see Elsie being developed spiritually through her relationship with God.
You are here
Character development is an essential part of a good book, and I found this element lacking in Elsie She starts off perfect and weepy and ends perfect and weepy She's like the Christian version of the Mary Sue. View all 5 comments. Oct 02, Alisha rated it it was amazing. Amazing book that teaches morals and standards. Growing up I learned a lot from Elsie, though only read this one book. She taught me how to stand up for what I believe in and love all who are around me no matter who they are.
To see the beauty in everyone. View 1 comment. Jan 28, Jenna rated it it was amazing.